Opinion | Joe Manchin is quietly pushing Democrats into an ACA catastrophe

Placeholder while article actions load

Stories about the potential expiration of enhanced Affordable Care Act insurance subsidies often refer to the issue as the “Obamacare time bomb.” And for good reason: If Democrats don’t solve this problem soon, millions of Americans will see their health insurance premiums spike at the beginning of 2023.

And letters informing enrollees of increased premiums would start going out in October — just before the midterm elections.

As of now, Sen. Joe Manchin III appears to be the primary obstacle to renewing the enhanced subsidies, which originally passed in the American Rescue Plan. Though the West Virginia Democrat is in negotiations with his party’s leaders about some sort of extension of the subsidies, if this doesn’t happen, he’ll be the reason.

As bad as this appears, there are other hidden reasons this is suddenly so urgent. First, if it isn’t resolved within the next month, states might need to assume it won’t happen and act accordingly. Second, if Democrats can’t get Manchin to come around, they risk squandering a political advantage on health care that took them literally a decade to build.

The 2021 pandemic relief bill included enhanced subsidies under the ACA for people who buy private insurance on the exchanges. Around 13 million Americans benefited from them, allowing them to pay significantly less for their health coverage. For many people, it reduced insurance costs down to zero.

An extension of the enhanced subsidies was supposed to be part of Build Back Better — but Manchin killed that bill. His comments on the extension have been vague; he has said he’s open to it, but wants to make sure the subsidies don’t go to wealthy families. Yet the subsidies are already means-tested, and always have been.

In his negotiations with Democratic leaders about whether parts of BBB can be salvaged — including renewing the ACA subsidies — Manchin has insisted on bringing down the deficit. That seems to make joining an enhanced subsidy extension with prescription drug reform — which would save huge amounts that could then offset the cost of the subsidy extension — a requirement.

But if the enhanced subsidies disappear at the end of the year, 3 million people will lose their coverage because it will become unaffordable for them, and another 8.9 million will see their premiums rise by an average of $406, according to the Department of Health and Human Services.

“We have a big sense of urgency about this,” Rep. Suzan DelBene (D-Wash.), head of the New Democrat Coalition of moderate and front-line Democrats, told us.

DelBene notes that Congress must act to renew the subsidies by the end of July. If not, she said, states will have to assume that they’re going to expire, and deliver notices of rate increases.

What’s more, this threatens to squander a political advantage that Democrats have painfully built up on the health-care issue over the course of years. Recall the larger context: After Democrats passed the ACA in 2010, they confidently predicted the public would come to like it. But that took far longer than expected.

Democrats lost dozens of House seats in the 2010 midterms,…

Read More: Opinion | Joe Manchin is quietly pushing Democrats into an ACA catastrophe

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More